MCINTOSH C500 C/P/T

MJ19.09.2009

Preamplifiers

Any McIntosh product can be recognized from a distance. One would not mistaken chromed retro-knobs, gothic lettering, grave black fascias and oversized blue-lit meters for anything else. One single McIntosh looks impressive in a dark room but nothing equals the orgasm of having the room bathed in the icy light of multiple McIntosh devices.

Function and form

88%
Ease of use
56%
Sound
96%
Appearance

In McIntosh they resigned on listening to the laments of both audiophile camps and developed a "dual" preamplifier for both solid-state and vacuum-tube lovers. Thus, they assume, a listener can adapt the style to its mood or to the recorded material. The set of the C500 consists of not less than three separate devices: the C500C Controller and the C500P and C500T preamps. The former is all vacuum-tube (4x12AX7A plus 4x12AX7A for phono), the latter is solid-state. All three packed in separate but identical enclosures (44,5x13,7x15,2cm). Complement them with two monoblocks and - voila - you will have impressive stack of five devices in the typical retro McIntosh style.

The connectivity of the Controller is also impressive: 4x balanced XLR input,  4x single ended RCA input, 3x XLR output, 2x RCA output and  a tape loop. The preamps are controlled through the Controller so there are no controls on them. The chromed knobs on the C500C looks like analogue ones but they are not - the user can program the software options with them. I am not going to describe in detail what can be done as the manual of the 3-piece set up is thick. Suffice to say that the user can do anything (for example, to regulate the load for MC cartridges continuously between 25 and 1000 ohms, among others).

I liked how McIntosh solved the volume regulation: the position of the volume knob is detected by infrared sensors. The convertor then converts the signal from the sensors to digital pulses which are used by a volume control processor.

Bass management

Weight
88
Slam
76
Articulation
66

The first thing I was after during this review was to find the sonic differences between C500P and C500T. According the manual the only difference is in S/N ratio and distortion (100dB and 0,002% for the solid-state, 93dB and 0,05% for the vacuum-tube).

After hours of listening it was clear that the tubed C500T leaves its signature on sound. The soundstage is wider and flatter. For example, the proportions between positions of horns and strings in Saint-Saens' Dance Macabre (Charles Dutoit and Philharmonia Orchestra) were distorted and became too compact and homogenous.

One would expect (an audiophile clichee) the C500T to be warm but it was  not. The tonality of instruments was honest without any coloration. The C500T was pretty much sounding neutral irrespective of which loudspeakers were used. It were transients where I could hear the 'contribution" of the C500T. The violin pizzicato was too soft, fingers on strings blurred. The harpist as if wore gloves. The double bass lacked punch. And so on. The sound becomes muted, dark and more comfortable than it should be. My initial good impression from the weighty bass dissapereard by realizing that the definition was the trade off.

Clarity & delicacy

Detail
72
Air
79
Transparency
66

When I increased the volume step by step the C500T soon was short of breath. The preamplifier lost its control over the electronic sound pastiche of Nine Inch Nails at high volume levels.

Tonal accuracy

Timbre
73
Dynamics
72
Temporal resolution
70

The C500T is audibly more organized. It is not huge difference but let's say it is different enough to hear the improvement. The most notable change is the absence of the dark and muted signature. The other welcome change arrived at high volumes when the C500T did not disintegrate and keep control. How about the harp? The harpist took off the gloves, thumbs up. The string's attack was faster and better contoured. The velvety soft sound was transformed into something more real, truer to the original.

Spatial resolution

Holography
81
Soundstage width
86
Soundstage depth
84

The bass was also much more articulated through the C500P. The generous bloatiness disappeared, the sound was more punchy and clearer. With the C500P the soundstage was alike with the C500T - more width than depth.

I spent quite a lot of time by switching forth and back between both the preamps on voices.  The C500T provided more comfort and ease, whereas the C500P was more precise and open. But hey, isn't it what McIntosh wanted to achieve? Just adapt your preamp to the program material you listen to at the moment...

Price as reviewed:500 000,- Kč

Recommended resellers

HI-FI studio TYKON, Ostrava, tel. +420 723 449 894

PP HiFi Studio, Otrokovice, tel. +420 603 581 305

Associated components

  • Sources: McIntosh MVP871, BMC BD CD1 a DAC1
  • Amplifiers: McIntosh C500C Controller and C500P and C500T preamps
  • Interconnects and speaker cables: Rapport, Luxman
  • Loudspeakers: Cabasse Karissima, Usher CP-8571 Diamond DMD
  • Power conditioning: Audioquest NRG-2, WSS N2 Power G

Gallery

ACCUPHASE C-3800

Nature works with infinite number of colors – hifi & high end components have very limited palettes, however. Fortunately we have already passed the black & white point yet a real orchestra sounds different from what one usually ...

Recommended resellers

Nisel SK, Bratislava, tel. +421 905 203 078

Sound
92%

AUDIOMAT Opus 2

Philosophically speaking, how it is possible that the Audiomat listeners say that the voice of Frank Sinatra in Nice & Easy is perfectly realistic, undistorted and tonally correct? None of them have ever had a chance to hear ...

Recommended resellers

Interaudio SK, Komárno, tel. +421 905 884 677

Sound
78%

BEL CANTO Pre3

It was as if the recording venue had new air filters installed and an extra dose of oxygen was pumped in during a performance – the sense of vertigo was very strong and I did not want to return back to the ´dusty´sound of everything ...

Recommended resellers

Hanzel Audio, Komárno, tel. +421 905 400 770

Sound
64%

BESPOKE AUDIO passive preamplifier

This passive preamplifier is unprecedented. The level of customer care that is out into conceiving every single unit is amazing and throws you back in time, when shoes were made by shoemakers rather than chosen from a full shelves in ...

Recommended resellers

HI-FI studio TYKON, Ostrava, tel. +420 723 449 894

Sound
99%

BOULDER 812

The Boulder 812 is a modern front-end that puts a preamplifier, a DAC, and a headphone amplifier under one hood. Although the brand is synonymous with boulder-like behemoths, the 812 is surprisingly smal. It has a square footprint of ...

Sound
85%

CONSTELLATION AUDIO Pictor/Taurus

The funny fact about the Constellation Audio’s Pictor preamplifier and Taurus stereo power amplifier: in the company’s amplifier hierarchy they are a part of Revelation series which is a ‘compact car’ in automotive terminology. The ...

Recommended resellers

No distributor at the time of the review.

Sound
95%

CREEK OBH-22

The Creek OBH-22 was a heart-stopper. When I substitued different preamps with it or when I used it as a front end of integrated amplifiers, it did not do anything that would impair the sound. So actually it did what it was supposed ...

Recommended resellers

High-End Audio Studio, Praha, tel. +420 224 256 844

Sound
20%
Back to category